Showing posts with label litigant in person. Show all posts
Showing posts with label litigant in person. Show all posts

Monday, 15 September 2014

Face to Face Support - FNF Central London

The primary goal of The Custody Minefield is to provide family law information for those without legal representation, lay advisers and charity sector staff (some in the legal profession and other professionals find it quite handy too).

Other organisations provide 1-to-1 support, and one of these is the charity Families Need Fathers (FNF). FNF, despite its name, helps both mums and dads, and in addition to a helpline and internet based forums, has local branches across the country where you can meet with other parents going through separation and find face-to-face support. A vital lifeline for many litigants-in-person.

Much of this work is done by volunteers, who receive no plaudits, little public recognition, but who work to help others, year in, year out.

One such is Vincent McGovern, Chair of Families Need Fathers' largest and oldest branch, who we've invited to explain what his branch does, his personal role and work, and that of the Central London Committee.

FNF's Central London Branch have their own web page, with details of Branch Meetings.

Visit: Families Need Fathers - Central London Branch

We're happy to publicise details of organisations which support parents ...and after this brief introduction, I'll leave you in Vincent's hands...

Branch Meetings
The Central London Branch of Families Need Fathers is the founding branch of FNF established in 1974. It is also the busiest and largest with between 900-1,000+ attendees each year. 

We have meetings to offer separating and separated parents support, every Monday at 8 pm apart from Bank Holidays and Christmas. Meetings are held in a private function room at the Crosse Keys Pub, 9 Gracechurch Street, and near Bank underground station.

Newcomers are not obliged to speak and are welcome to observe – we like to provide a relaxed, pressure free forum for discussion.

Our Attendees
People often ask me what type of person attends our meetings. My reply always is “normal people unfortunate enough to find themselves in unfortunate circumstances.”

The majority of our attendees are dads, but we are gender blind and help any mother who is the non-resident parent. Quite often younger dads have their mothers or sisters accompanying them. Our whole raison d’etre is to support the children having a proper involvement with both parents, post divorce or separation, unless there is proven danger.

The Crosse Keys Meeting Venue
Legal Support at our Meetings
We have a specialist Solicitor clinic on the first Monday of every month for members only from 6-8 pm. We owe a deep appreciation to the family law firm Anthony Gold and Co, who have provided this important pro bono service for decades. Quite often we have the benefit of a senior partner from that firm which is very helpful for nervous frightened attendees.

For the past year at most meetings we have also benefitted from the assistance of Austin Chessell, a family law solicitor and mediator, also a Trustee of FNF, which enables whoever is Chairing the meeting that night, giving advice, to have a professional referee for validity of comment.

As well as solicitor support, McKenzie Friends (lay legal advisers) are on hand to provide support and assistance.

We wish to make clear that no adviser (solicitor or otherwise) charges for their time at our meetings, and again sincerely thank all, who over many years have given up their time to help thousands of parents and their children.

Confidentiality
All of our meetings are held under Chatham House rules, no repetition of discussions outside of the meeting, no recording, first names only and NEVER ever reveal the names and addresses of parties to anyone. This basic housekeeping causes some problems for newcomers who are quite often emotional (understandably) but it is an absolute requirement for us as a branch and helps the attendee to focus as sometimes they are in deep shock. Confidentiality is important not just to these parents, but their children as well.

Work of the Central London Branch (CLB) Committee
We hold committee meetings every three months dealing with such matters as housekeeping, rota for chairing meetings, liaising between ourselves and FNF HQ, also other branches, financial management etc. The committee of CLB never charges expenses for attending all these meetings, a considerable burden in itself. However, this means CLB has the funds for limited campaigning, assisting some truly desperate members with court fees, train fare to and from meetings, etc and on occasions helping the national charity at AGM’s etc. 

We normally have the full contingent of seven committee members at each branch meeting, as meeting every week requires considerable time input from officers.

Committee members are elected, each year, at the Branch AGM. We're a democratic group!

About Me
I first joined FNF/CLB in December 2007. Ironically I delayed joining as I discovered they met above a pub and I incorrectly assumed they were just a bunch of angry dads drinking and "sounding off". That false impression was quickly dispelled at my first meeting. A few months later I was invited onto CLB committee.

My views on post-separation and our legal and welfare system
It remains a perversity that, especially when parents are likely to be in heightened emotional state following a relationship break up, the court too often encourages post-separation dispute by handing control and a means of punishment to one over the other.

As Sir Nicholas Mostyn, a judge in the High Court, said in a past judgment, "if parents were behaving well, they'd probably still be together" but ours is an adversarial legal system. My own view is that the term adversial should have no place in the family courts. Our family courts should be inquisitorial and facilitative.

I can say, with clarity, that too often our family law system does fail children and still contains elements of gender bias. I've seen house husbands relegated to alternate weekend contact parents after separation, with little thought to maintaining the status quo for the children. Why... because of their gender and some judges remaining out of touch with the contemporary household. In so many homes across the country, both parents take an active role in their children's lives. In the new millennium, research finds mums and dads equally involved (Equalities Commission Research, 2008), yet after court, too often arrangements are imposed which hark back to a 1970s ethos. Countless studies confirm child welfare benefits when both parents are fully involved in their children's lives.

I've seen too many instances where there has been malpractice in welfare services, and four Ombudsman Investigations (with findings against) in a single case I've had involvement with. Findings confirmed institutional malpractice within children’s and legal services. Two of these were Parliamentary and Health Services Ombudsman investigations with findings against Brent Primary Care Trust and Cafcass. Sadly, findings such as these, while a moral victory, result in zero change on the ground. We need an ethos within UK Children's Services where the primary motivation is raising standards rather than defending reputations.

Too often, our courts fail to safeguard a child's relationships, or protect them from the emotional harm caused by an alienating parent. There is too little enforcement of Court Orders (Ref Hansard 25 February 2013, column 113).

So much opportunity for a more family friendly legal system was lost with the final revisions to the Children Act in 2014. UK MPs were too influenced by powerful lobby groups, and misinformed. An example being their holding that a presumption of shared parenting was unsuccessful in Australia, when no such finding existed. Such was the opinion of Professor Parkinson of the Sydney Law School, whose criticism included that the UK Family Justice Review misrepresented the findings of Australian research. At our branch, we deal with the fall out of political failure.

The expression ‘Welfare of the Child’ has become an expression of convenience quite often unrelated to children’s welfare or needs but most beneficial, ideologically and financially, to the myriad virtually unregulated and effectively unaccountable services involved. Big business meets a nigh on unaccountable public sector lacking in checks and balances. As an MEP said to me in Brussels, “when income generation is more important than welfare of children then we have systemic failing.”

This is the reason why I moved my energies to lobbying in the European Parliament. The difference with Westminster could not have been more stark. The MEP’s have extensive knowledge of the shortcomings within UK Family Courts and associated services. Fortunately Ombudsman Investigations mean something in Brussels, and the fact I could submit details of four (mentioned above) leant weight to my submissions. On March 19th this year I had the privilege of briefly addressing the petitions Commission of the European Parliament on it’s motion ‘Systemic Failings within UK Family Courts and Children’s Services.’ The title was apt. I am deeply grateful to FNF's Central London Branch for always supporting my work attempting to bring about the much needed improvements in these services.

Our branch and other FNF branches help parents navigate the courts as they stand today. My hope remains for a better system in the future.

Friday, 13 December 2013

More training needed for HMCTS on Lay Advice

Two recent incidents highlight the lack of knowledge among both magistrates' clerks and HMCTS staff regarding litigants in person, permissions required for lay advice and the role of the McKenzie Friend.

The first being a litigant in person told they cannot seek lay advice about matters relating to proceedings without the permission of the court. In this matter, the clerk confused permission for a McKenzie Friend to accompany a litigant into court (which does require the court's permission) with a litigant seeking confidential advice (which does NOT require the court's permission).

Family Procedure Rule 12.75 covers the matter of who advice might be sought from, and the circumstances. Common sense should dictate this though. Otherwise, how would the Citizen's Advice Bureau exist, let alone the other organisations which provide lay advice.

The second matter being a litigant in person having been told by court staff to have their McKenzie Friend contact solicitors for the other side over a recent application. The McKenzie Friend is prohibited from doing this and MAY NOT act as the litigant's agent or manage their case outside of court. The Law Society practice note on litigants in person expressly states that if a solicitor receives correspondence from a McKenzie Friend, they should reply back to the litigant in person (6.1). The President's Practice Guidance on McKenzie Friends and the Legal Services Act 2007 also apply.


Monday, 9 December 2013

flApp v.2 - Family Law Support for 2014

In January 2014 we launch our new Family Law App... flApp v.2

2006 saw our first venture into family law information for separating parents, and The Custody Minefield book reached no.2 on Amazon's Divorce Chart. A reviewer in the Magistrates Magazine said it would 'save parents a fortune in legal fees'. The Divisional Chair of the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy described it as a 'gem of information'.

The law isn't static, and print media soon becomes out-of-date. With legal aid being abolished and charity funding being cut, litigants the need for detailed support information has become even greater. I often am asked 'can you recommend a good family law book?' Not if it was written more than a year ago. The Low Commission (tasked with investigating support tools to plug the hole left by legal aid cuts) calls for action by 'the next Government'. Parents and their children need help now! Not after the next election.

In 2012, we launched our first web based application. This grew into a behemoth of information, as more and more content was added covering an ever wider array of situations and circumstances. We feared this was becoming overwhelming for the user.

When building this new version, we faced three dilemmas.

1. We wanted more content, not less. Something easily accessible, but not dumbed down. The volume of content needed thoughtful structuring,  in a more user friendly format.

2. We felt the volume of information in our first app was too overwhelming for some litigants, and especially when they are hindered by stress... but that depth of information is necessary to ensure the litigant can be properly armed, to achieve an 'equality in arms' (or as close as we could get it).

3. We were aware that a number of charities have support staff who use our guides, as do some McKenzie Friends. Specific guides would need to be quickly accessed while an adviser is on the phone, or with a parent or grandparent, face-to-face. Different users would need to access information in different ways.

In short, our goal was to provide more information, in a more accessible format, which was not overwhelming for the user, and would be of benefit to both the novice litigant and experienced adviser on family law.

This has been no easy feat. The new app answers many hundreds of questions and we estimate has 1,000,000 words of content (we stopped counting after 850,000).

Accessibility - Design
Accessibility is critical for any application. The format will need to work across all popular phones, tablet, e-reader, and desktop platforms. The design needs to cater for touch screen or keyboard usage. It does!

Accessibility - Structure
Rather than a long list of guides, we've opted for content specific, menu driven access, which breaks information into 'digestible' chunks, and where the user is lead from guide to guide.

The litigant-in-person (new to family law) chooses the first button 'Resolving Disputes', whereupon they're taken to a stage by stage, guide to the legal process.

Step 1: Pre-Litigation (guides on mediation, handling stress, helping children cope etc).
Step 2: Applying to Court (everything from orders explained, to the application process, forms etc)
Step 3: The first hearing (the FHDRA explained, position statements, the role of CAFCASS, confidentiality, courts and judges, etc)
Step 4: Directions and interim hearings (bundles, statements, collating evidence, investigations etc)
Step 5: Contested/Final hearings (preparation, bundles, scott schedules, skeleton arguments, submissions etc).

Simple guides on most other sites simply fail to cover more complex situations, and don't provide information which the litigant needs. What does a 'statement' look like? How should it be structured? What goes into a skeleton argument? What on earth is a Scott Schedule or the Witness Template? Who can I ask for advice (a question some court clerks appear confused on, when telling litigants they can't speak to lay advisers without the court's consent... you can!)?

So we go into detail... 

Taking Leave to Remove as an example (where one parent seeks to take a child to live abroad and the other parent opposes the move), our guides provide information as to what the court considers important, steps you may take, domestic as well as international legislation, and case law.

If your children are missing, you come home and the house is empty, if your children are at risk of removal abroad, suffering abuse or neglect, are being alienated from you or it's disputed whether you're their parent... you'll find practical information to assist you, referenced to the latest court judgments, and all commonly asked questions are answered.

Accessibility - Choices
If you know what you want, and would sooner not search through menus, we're introducing Oscar. Using page specific meta-tags, Oscar, our search agent, hunts for specific content.

Oscar searches through guides, menus and case law. Regarding case law searches, you can search using the area of law (e.g. contact disputes, parental alienation, leave to remove, internal relocation, shared residence etc...). If you remember the year and the judge who heard the case, Oscar can bring up cases heard by a specific judge or in a given year. If you know the neutral citation number, that's fine too (but how many of us do!). In short, Oscar is your dedicated family law librarian and can be accessed as a 'pop up' on any page with the press of a button.


For the new litigant, we've added a legal dictionary, which again can be accessed from any page, and being a 'pop up' screen, you don't have to leave the page you're on to decipher legal language (and then lose your place)!

For telephone support staff who need instant access to information, we've added a full content list, which again can be pulled up as a popup, and content accessed in this way opens up as a new window (allowing multiple windows to be open at once). 


Version 2, launching in January 2014, will have case law in both html (on screen) and a downloadable alternative (in a pdf format) should litigants want to provide the court with a skeleton argument supported by a reading list and hard copy case law. Where cited in guides as an indication of matters the court considers in specific circumstances, hyperlinks take the user straight to the judgment.


Version 3 will launch in April 2014, in anticipation of changes to the family courts. The modular design structure allows us to update content... fast ... and we'll have some new surprises for you!