Showing posts with label leave to remove. Show all posts
Showing posts with label leave to remove. Show all posts

Friday, 6 March 2015

Case Law: Leave to Remove - "You can't hug Skype"

Case Reference: Re R (A Child: Relocation) [2015] EWHC 456 (Fam)

The mother sought leave to remove to enable her to relocate the child to Hong Kong to take up employment there. This case made headlines (in the Daily Mail) for the observation that Skype was no panacea to a lack of physical contact. The judge observed:
"Miss D. thought that Skype could be beneficial for a child even as young as two because the child could see who they were talking to, but the mother's proposals do not take account of time lag, competing interests in a child's life, what a two year old talks about on consecutive days, etc. Also leaving aside the technology and timing issues, the disadvantages of Skype - as any user will know - are all too often the lack of clarity of image, the sound delay even if short, and, as Miss Mills colourfully notes in her closing submissions, "You can't hug Skype".
The mother's past conduct in relation to contact and what might be viewed as controlling tendencies and a lack of recognition of the importance of the father's role in the child';s upbringing were also significant factors in her leave to remove application being refused.

Where the relocating parent is proposing Skype/telephone contact with young children, this judgment is worth bringing to the court´s attention, and the Honourable Mr Justice Wood's opinion as to Skype (given his tech-savvy experience... which isn't always universal among CAFCASS and the judiciary).

This judgment shows the detailed, critical analysis of proposals and history which is essential in leave to remove cases, and in our opinion, exemplary.

The judgment is available to read via the links below:

Re R (A Child: Relocation) [2015] EWHC 456 (Fam) - Online
Re R (A Child: Relocation) [2015] EWHC 456 (Fam) - Download

Friday, 16 January 2015

Guide and Case Law Updates - Leave to Remove

http://www.thecustodyminefield.com/flapp/tlfjcaselawmenu.html
Our first new content for 2015 and updates to earlier content have just been published. These include:
  1. a new case law library, on Temporary Removal from the Jurisdiction (initially cases related to a child's temporary removal to non-Hague Convention member states);
  2. a brief summary and full html and pdf versions of judgments are provided where in the public domain;
  3. an update to the guide on Leave to Remove, paying reference to Mostyn J's summing up of guidance in NJ v OV [2014] EWHC 4130 (Fam);
  4. the broken link to the certificate referred to in Article 41 of EC Council Regulation No. 2201/2003 has been fixed;
  5. a review of our Leave to Remove Case Law Library with html and pdf versions of NJ v OV [2014] EWHC 4130 (Fam) added;
  6.  a review and update to the countries that are party to the 1980 Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction.
Happy New Year to you all, and we'll have more content coming.

Tuesday, 8 July 2014

Leave to Remove - New Case Law - P (Children)

http://www.thecustodyminefield.com/flapp/caselaw/2014-ewca-civ-852.html
P (Children) [2014] EWCA Civ 852

A successful appeal against a leave to remove decision, with the judgment set aside and an order that the case be reheard.

Ryder accepted that the court had placed too great an emphasis on motive as reason for refusing leave to remove. While there had been acrimony at the time the relationship had broken down, the "mother had not refused contact or breached a court order."

Ryder goes on to point out that other matters were not given sufficient examination, such as the mother's plans in Germany (accommodation, employment etc) and the extent of the relationship between the children and parents.
"15. There are other issues between the parties, but in the context that I have come to the conclusion that the order must be set aside and the application re heard, I do not propose to express any detailed view about the same, save to say that a relatively superficial view was taken of accommodation that was available in Germany and also a superficial view of the financial needs and obligations of the parties to each other and the employment prospects of the mother in Germany.  Likewise, the strength of, that is the nature and extent of the relationship of each parent and the children, was relatively superficially addressed.  Those questions, alongside other welfare factors, need to be re explored without what became the dominant question of motivation which became decisive in the way that it did."
The judgment highlights the importance of not being overly reliant on a single point, and more importantly, not where there is insufficient evidence to support that point.

What needs to be properly explored is whether relocation is in the child's best interests, and the examination and balancing of all the welfare matters, motive and the practicalities related to the parents' plans (including the enforceability of contact, even if relocation is to a country covered by the Brussels II Revised Regulations). On this last point, while a contact order may, in principle, be enforceable in another EU member state, can the UK based parent afford the costs related to enforcement in another jurisdiction? Recent submissions to the EU Petition's Commission by a German father and Mr McGovern of Families Need Fathers suggest this is not as straightforward as some may believe.

Friday, 4 July 2014

New Case Law: Leave to Remove

http://www.thecustodyminefield.com/flapp/caselaw/2014-EWFC-11.html
H v F (Relocation) [2014] EWFC 11 does not provide new points of law, but is worth discussing none the less, and carries an important message.

The court was faced with a stark choice, a very young child relocating to New Zealand or remaining in the UK. Either situation would result in one or other parent having contact over some considerable distance and have an impact on their relationship with their child, and their child's relationship with them. Both parents were fully involved in the child´s care before separation, and both capable of providing adequate care. The mother had no support network in the UK.

The father had a visa to work in New Zealand so the parties were not on an equal footing in terms of their immigration status.

The maternal grandparents had maintained a non-combative stance, something which the paternal grandmother had failed to achieve. Additionally, the father had made allegations about the mother, and the court had formed an opinion that the father was highly critical of the mother, and if he became the parent with whom the child lived in the UK, the court was uncertain whether he would fairly represent the mother to the child.

Allegations by the father, including that the mother was a habitual drug user, were found to be untrue.
Litigants should note the risks of what may be viewed as an unreasonably combative stance, or in making allegations without evidence to support them.

An important factor in leave to remove cases are the parent´s willingness to promote contact and support contact.

Parents often forget that an important aspect of cases is credibility, how they present in court, and the approach they, not just related to proceedings, but to their ex-partner in general. When dramatic changes to one's life are being considered, it's understandable that parents become stressed, anxious and fearful. It's commonplace, and especially in leave to remove/relocation cases. At times, that emotional reaction lends itself to taking too combative an approach, which risks undermining their case. 

If both parents are at each others' throats, the court may decide the child needs to be removed from the conflict, so leave to remove may be granted. If one parent is combative, in terms of allegations and their presentation in court, and the other is not, the combative parent risks the court forming the view that the other parent is more child focused and more likely to support and promote contact.

In terms of allegations, it's important to raise the question as to whether something is a risk, or a real risk.

I don't view this case as representing a re-emergence of the distress argument in leave to remove cases as a dominant factor, as some may fear. There are a number of mitigating factors for leave to remove being granted. That said, there is an important lesson in the judgment, in that every course of action carries potential risks and rewards. To my mind, and in my experience, the combative approach is a high risk strategy and often unwise, and an approach best avoided unless there is very clear and compelling evidence to support that anxiety is justified, and that risks are very real. Not just a 'tactic' for court, but for life after.
 http://www.thecustodyminefield.com/flapp/caselaw/2014-EWFC-11.html

Sunday, 22 June 2014

Family Law App: Help with Crisis Situations and More

http://www.thecustodyminefield.com/flapp/crisismenu.html

In the event you missed it, we've built our Crisis Menu into our main Resolving Disputes section.

You'll find practical, step-by-step answers and approaches to the most common crisis situations, whether your children and ex-partner are missing, you're facing a psychological assessment, there is risk of domestic violence, the children are at immediate risk of harm, it's disputed you're the father, you're not seeing your child, you face false allegations or your ex-partner is threatening to take the children abroad or move some distance away.

Whether or not the parent faces these crisis situations, knowledge of what you might do in these situations can reassure and reduce stress. 

Sections on Contact Enforcement, Internal Relocation, Leave to Remove, Parental Alienation and Paternity Testing will have dedicated case law libraries in support. We should have this section of the project concluded within the next two weeks (three of these libraries are already live, and we'll be reviewing case law as we go).

http://www.thecustodyminefield.com/flapp/welfaremenu.html
New on our Resolving Disputes Menu is a dedicated Welfare and CAFCASS section, including guides on CAFCASS, Family Assistance Orders, the role of the Guardian-Ad-Litem, Parenting Information Programmes, and a new page giving suggestions when meeting CAFCASS. 

Click on any of the images to be taken directly to those pages or use the links.



Thursday, 4 October 2012

Press Release - A lifeline for families as legal aid cuts bite

Press Release

'A lifeline for families as legal aid cuts bite'
05 October 2012

Legal aid cuts are expected in April 2013, and the Government estimates that legal representation is to be lost in 50,000 cases (of which 45,000 are in the private family law arena). Many families are struggling to find a legal aid solicitor now as professionals exit the industry and firms close.

Since learning this, we developed a range of resources for parents and grandparents who simply cannot afford to privately employ a solicitor. Today we officially launch the first part of our lifeline:

The Family Law Web Based Application: A bit of a mouthful, so we shortened the name to flApp. We wanted a resource which puts a vast quantity of family law information at a parent's or grandparent's fingertips. Over half a million words of content, 8 case law categories, 250 questions answered, case law to view online or download in hard copy, court process guides, key international and national legislation… 60 categories of information. Accessible on PCs, smart phones, tablets and macs. We include minimal graphics to cut internet usage costs, and pages are designed to be viewed on any platform, but especially mobile phones… even better, flApp is free.

Litigation Packs: Process guides helping the litigant through each stage of court proceedings. We have information to help them write a statement, put together a court bundle, attend a first dispute and resolution hearing or mediation  and much more. We talk them through, step by step, and include the forms and documents they need. We charge a minimal fee of £2.50 which goes towards site running costs.


Case Law on Kindle: For the unrepresented parent and lay advisers (McKenzie Friends) we have launched four case law packs which are available on Amazon in a kindle format. These cover shared residence, parental alienation, internal relocation and leave to remove.

“Internal Relocation”: The first of our new guides on specific and more complex areas of private family law... Internal Relocation. Written for parents whose children live in England and Wales, this book explains private family law  related to relocation. Such situations typically arise after parental separation and when the primary  carer seeks to move the child(ren) away from the area of the family home to another part of England or Wales. Their motives may be genuine (such as seeking new employment or moving closer to other family members) or malicious (to place distance between the children and their non-relocating parent).

The guide comes in a kindle format and in three parts. The first gives an analysis of relocation law, the second is a court process guide specific to internal relocation cases, while the third includes the full text of case law related to internal relocation.

Support Forum: Our new support forum is especially tailored for mobile phones and staffed by an experienced team from the third sector who have collectively answered more than 10,000 posts.

Case Law for iPad: Design complete, and cloud based versions are now available. We will be converting them to an app version soon.

All available at www.thecustodyminefield.com

The Custody Minefield is a leading provider of family law information for parents, charities, grandparents, step parents and the wider family. Many who use our site do so from libraries and internet cafes. Our guides are currently viewed some 40,000 times a month.

Take the video tour


Family law at your fingertips


Thursday, 14 June 2012

We've new content on The Custody Minefield site... 3 case law collections... FREE!

Now you can read judgments and other reference material on your kindle, ipad, iphone or tablet reader, using free kindle software and with content reformatted by us. You'll need to download Amazon's free Kindle software from here to be able to open and read our Kindle format reference guides. More case law is available on our CASE LAW page.

You can also download Case Law as a pdf to print and include in your court bundles and skeleton arguments.

Saturday, 3 September 2011

Updated Content - Leave to Remove Case Law

In the July 2011 judgment K (Children) [2011] EWCA Civ 793, there is mention of a case which at that time was unreported, and where leave to remove was refused in the High Court.

"139. Very recently Theis J in C v D [2011] EWHC 335 (Fam) took the same approach as Hedley J in a case in which the children spent 20 days with their mother/10 days with their father during term time and the holidays were split equally."

In C v D, heard in the High Court by Mrs Justice Theis DBE, it is worth noting her judgment based on considerations set out in the Welfare Checklist (section 1(3) of The Children Act 1989) and her finding that relocation was not in the children's best interests, despite accepting that her decision would be devastating to the mother who wished to emigrate with the children.

"65. Having carefully considered all the evidence and the welfare checklist I have come to the clear conclusion that the welfare of each of these children is met by the mother's application being refused. I recognise that this will be devastating for the mother but I have come to this conclusion primarily based on the evidence that the children are thriving under the regime the parents have devised in this jurisdiction and the adverse impact on their time and relationship with their father if they did move to south USA. For the reasons set out above I do not believe it can be effectively replicated if the children move to south USA and that any different regime will not meet the children's needs. With the welfare of these children as the lodestar by which I am guided I am satisfied that the move to south USA would not meet the welfare needs of these children, however disappointing that decision will be for the mother."

The case C v D is now added to our Case Law for Kindle - Leave to Remove Case Law Reference Book which includes the following cases:

K (Children) [2011] EWCA Civ 793
Re Y (Leave to Remove from Jurisdiction) [2004] FLR 330
Payne v Payne [2001] EWCA Civ 166
LinkAR (A Child: Relocation) [2010] EWHC 1346 (Fam)
C v D [2011] EWHC 335 (Fam)
W (Children) [2009] EWCA Civ 160
Re F (Children) [2003] EWCA Civ 592

The Kindle reference book now includes URL addresses and hyperlinks so that the case law can be downloaded to a PC in PDF format, and printed.

Saturday, 27 August 2011

Demographics, Leave to Remove and the Courts: The Ticking Time Bomb

A few years ago, leave to remove applications were comparitively rare when compared to other types of family law case (anecdotally, circa 1000 cases a year).

As reported in a number of broadsheet papers this week, the number of births in Britain to immigrant mothers is fast approaching 25% of all births. In London, it is already over 50%. In some boroughs, 75%.

You do not need to be a seer to realise that cases involving international relocation and abduction abroad are certain to increase and could overwhelm the courts and Foreign Office.

At the Custody Minefield, we're receiving more and more enquiries from parents seeking to prevent a leave to remove application. Already in 2011, we've experienced a 50% increase in our guides being viewed, compared to page views in all of 2010. A couple of years ago, emails about relocation cases mainly involved ones where emigration was a lifestyle choice. From what we're seeing in 2010, they more commonly involve a parent seeking to return to their country of birth, with cases involving returns to Europe, Eastern Europe, the USA, Canada, New Zealand, Australia and South America, but most commonly Poland and Pakistan. In all of these cases, the children had been born in the UK and had lived all their lives here.

About these latest birth statistics, shadow home secretary Dominic Grieve said: 'With births to foreign mothers becoming such a large driver of population growth, it is vital that immigration levels are set taking into account the ability of our schools, hospitals and other local services to cope.'

Have the Government or courts considered the impact on leave to remove applications and unlawful abductions abroad in the years which will follow?

The Family Justice Review Panel have specifically said that it is not within their remit to consider this area of law despite even senior members of the judiciary accepting the controversy that exists over the handling of these cases.

The Family Courts did review Payne v Payne earlier this year, which until that point was held to be both leading and binding case law in international child relocation cases. The review happened in the case K (Children) [2011] EWCA Civ 793, but was contradictory and inconclusive. The review followed much criticism that the courts paid too much attention to adult, rather than child welfare.

The review saw the courts slightly pull back somewhat from the adult centric guidance which had been followed since the Payne case. The Lord Justices of Appeal did not agree on which guidance should apply (depending on the particulars of the case), with Thorpe (Head of International Family Law) and Moore-Bick (Deputy Head of Civil Justice) holding that the guidance in Payne v Payne should not be a consideration where parents share care, while Lady Justice Black felt it should. All agreed that despite the controversy and criticism that the judge made guidance conflicts with Parliamentary statute, the guidance would still apply to cases where there was a primary carer.

Moore-Bick led us to believe that the only point of law ever to come from Payne v Payne was that child welfare must be the court's paramount consideration. Every family law case includes this point of law... so why was Payne considered binding precedent (as said to us by all preceeding Presidents of the Family Courts)? Why was it necessary to have this raised as a point in law, when that principle was laid out in statute? As a vanishing act, it wasn't particularly convincing, and rather than a white rabbit, the furry creature which Moore-Bick sought to make disappear was the judiciary having held adult welfare above child welfare in relocation cases which contravened the existing statute. The basis upon which relocation cases had been judged in the preceeding decade had 'contaminated the purity of the paramountcy principle' and due to the confused and contradictory ruling in K (Children), will continue to do so.

The main review point from the K (Children) judgment was that the wide ambit of judicial discretion should be unfettered, although this was muddied by the Lord Justices also saying that the guidance from Payne should be considered where there is a primary carer, and Lady Justice Black going further when she said it was useful in all external relocation cases. As a magic act, we were assured the rabbit had disappeared, but the head was clearly poking out of the magician's coat.

We are now seeing firms of solicitors asking for a £30,000 deposit from a parent needing representation in a case involving an international element, and their advising the parent that total costs could top £100,000. Why so much? The lack of detailed, child centric guidance and the inconsistency caused by the wide ambit of judicial discretion in considering these cases leads to lengthier and thus more expensive litigation.

This is compounded by the adversarial rather than inquisitorial nature of our family law system which leads to success being as much dependent on the skills of advocates and legal advisors as the facts of the case.

We believe the welfare checklist within the Children Act 1989 is too open to interpretation, and due to this, all family law cases concerning children become more uncertain, causing more lengthy litigation. Outcomes are inconsistent from court to court due to individual judicial discretion. We can only hope that at some point, the Government wakes up and considers the proposals that we and Families Need Fathers put forward to the Family Justice Review.

We are also seeing an increase in enquiries for information concerning unlawful child removals. Pakistan presents a particular problem in these circumstances. While an agreement exists between the UK and Pakistan courts setting out a protocol as to how these cases should be covered, the protocol was not ratified under Islamic law. One senior member of the legal profession in Pakistan commented that the UK/Pakistan Protocol was not worth the paper it was written on. Pakistan is not a signatory county to the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, and consequently, there is little practical help available to parents in the UK whose children are unlawfully removed to Pakistan.

Statistics from the Foreign and Commonwealth Office confirm that in the last year, the instances of one parent abducting their children abroad have increased by 10% and believe more cases go unreported.

Their response? A campaign to warn parents of the risks and prevention steps, and an admission that the assistance they can give is limited once the children have left the country. The reason being they cannot interfere with the law in foreign countries (not even when the unlawfully abducted child is a British national?).

The clock is ticking, and harm being done while the Ministry of Justice sleeps. Sadly, it is probably only the explosion in cases that will wake them, and by then, it will be too late.

Thursday, 11 August 2011

Family Law Week - Relocation Article




Michael Robinson of The Custody Minefield and Relocation Campaign responds to the recent articles by Richard Gregorian and Gavin Emerson concerning leave to remove applications, Payne v Payne and post-Payne development.

Read the full article on Family Law Week

Sunday, 24 July 2011

Why Kindle... and new content added and coming!

Tonight we've added a further piece of case law to our Leave to Remove Case Law for Kindle.

F (Children) [2003] EWCA Civ 592 confirmed that shared residence orders may be made, even when the parents' homes are separated by some considerable distance.

A question I've been asked is "why Kindle?"

We have also published a smartphone guide recently on Dyslexia and the Family Courts, and we want to make our own content more accessible in the coming months.

Kindle has a number of advantages. Firstly, if you have bought one of those slim, lightweight e-book readers, you will know that there is the option of 'text to speech' (when you can enjoy a slightly robotic voice reading to you). The screens are matt, solving the 'glare' problem that comes from pc screens and standard printed paper, which can pose a problem for people with dyslexia. The font is standardised and simple. We are cutting underlining and italics to a minimum, mindful that again, such things can make text harder to digest for someone with dyslexia.

Due to the simple formatting on kindle books, file sizes are kept to a minimum. This makes the format ideal for downloading and then storing large quantities of information. For McKenzie Friends and Litigants-in-Person heading into court, we want to provide information at your fingertips. Barristers are starting to take IPads into court. Not all of us can afford an IPad, but kindle books can also be read on smart phones, other tablet readers, pcs, macs, and of course, kindle readers, making the format accessible on a wide range of hardware.

Kindle content requires kindle software to be downloaded, but the ebook viewing software is free. With Amazon backing it, kindle books are already outselling paperbacks.

Visit The Custody Minefield to download the first of our kindle reference titles. You'll also find 38 free, simple html guides that can be viewed quickly on a smart phone.

Our goal for providing information for the coming year will be increasing accessibility (both in terms of format, and mindful of problems faced by parents and grandparents with specific learning difficulties or who are visually impaired). More content, and new guides will of course be coming, as well as the new formats for the existing guides and reference material.

Tuesday, 19 July 2011

Another first... Case Law for Kindle...FREE

Now you can read judgments on your kindle, ipad, iphone or tablet reader, using free kindle software.

We've especially formatted the leading case law on international child relocation (leave to remove) for viewing on Kindle readers and on other hardware using Amazon's free kindle reading software.

You'll need to download Amazon's free kindle software here to be able to open and read our Kindle format reference guides.

Click on the image above to download the case law, then copy it over to your preferred reading hardware and carry it with you to court, read it on the bus, in bed, or even on the loo!

Includes the new Re K (Children) judgment, Payne v Payne, Re Y and AR (Children).

Saturday, 9 July 2011

A very British Coup - Payne Reviewed?

The following is of course a fictitious interpretation of what has recently happened in the Royal Courts of Justice, concerning the quite astonishing, and long overdue review (civil court rescue of its family court cousin?) concerning the binding precedent of Payne v Payne. We are of course not reviewing or interpreting or amending what was said in court. Our sincere respects to Lord Justice Moore-Bicke (would he mind staying a while!) and Lady Justice Black, and of course, to Lord Justice Matthew Thorpe, our Head of International Family Law.

MB
"Now look into my eyes...

Let me introduce myself. I'm a new boy to family law, s
o bear with me if I appear a little callow. Well yes, I may be Deputy Head of Civil Justice, but I'm only here by chance, just filling in for the day!

Let us remind ourselves that our President of the Family Courts said a review of Payne wasn't possible in the Court of Appeal, so of course, this isn’t what we’ll be doing in court today. Sir Nicholas was of course quite right that only the Supreme Court or Parliament could review binding precedent *mumble*... yes I'm aware that if Payne had been applied 'per incuriam' - without care - then of course the Court of Appeal could make corrections, but that's not why I've been parachuted in *cough*, I mean why I am here by chance today
[and if it is held that I have reviewed Payne, I've covered myself quite nicely at paragraph 79... note well Lord Falconer, this is why judges should have an advocacy background and not come from the lesser ranks!].

So let me be quite clear, this judgment I am handing down today, in this case K (Children) does not include a review of Payne, oh no, not in the slightest. I've simply passed some comments on Payne, I'm not reviewing it at all, and I am not contradicting our President of the Family Courts.

Payne of course remains as precedent, but only in so far as it raised a single point of law (
look into my eyes)..."that child welfare must be the court's paramount consideration" [which of course needed to be emphasised in 2001 as a point of law, given that some of my colleagues appear not to have understood what paramountcy means - looking at no-one in particular].

I am aware that some will say that I am rewriting the guidance in Payne (the Solicitors Journal), but they're quite mistaken... not at all what I'm doing, I'd just like you to consider that the entire family justice profession and judiciary, with the notable exceptions of Hedley J and Elias LJ, have misunderstood and misapplied Payne v Payne for the last 11 years [so glad I come from the civil courts!]

We'll avoid mentioning the thousands of British families affected. The children who
have subsequently lost contact with the parents left behind due the court's additional
naivety at blindly believing so many 'primary carers' that they will of course support
contact once beyond the UK court's grasp. No point mentioning the emotional, psychological and developmental harm which relocation risks inflicting on our children. We can't turn the clock back, and they're no longer within our jurisdiction, so they're not British children now, strictly speaking, or our responsibility.

Clearly, there is little point in apportioning blame, when the only way to sack those responsible would be to have both Houses of Parliament vote to remove them from office, and that has only happened once in 250 years. Parliament's attention is understandably focused elsewhere.
[Could the timing of this judgment have been any better... thank heavens for the News of the World!]

Let us also avoid Matthew's quoting of statistics, and the fact that the Equalities Commission found in 2008 that fathers and mothers share care almost equally in today's society, and it is only once the courts become involved that this falls from almost 50% to the 3% that Matthew just quoted to you.

Let us also avoid mentioning the likelihood of harm caused to children by the court's position for the last 40 years, and that Briefing Report and evidence submitted at Westminster last November by The Custody Minefield and Families Need Fathers which highlighted that these risks of harm have been known since 2002, yet it has taken concerted campaigning to get the family courts to remember that their raison d'etre is safeguarding child welfare and not dogmatic wrangling over protocol.


*Cough* Moving swiftly on, I believe it is a more sensible resolution to say
that, what you believed Payne v Payne to have meant, and how it bound you all
wasn't in the slightest what the Lord Justices intended... was it Matthew... just nod old chap!

...and of course the guidance must be 'followed', as the President of the Family Courts said recently), what he actually meant was 'considered', since aside from the sole point of law concerning the paramountcy principle, it just provides some jolly useful tips, which of course should be considered, but that guidance is merely guidance, it isn't actually binding you see, and never was!


There has however been a jolly unfortunate misunderstanding, and had it not been for Matthew's slight slip in 2007 which caused this fuss, of using super-glue to apply guidance as precedent, we could all be doing something else this afternoon.

...and of course Re Y should be heeded by the judiciary where care is shared as Matthew so rightly just reminded you [after our little chat].


With reference to his comment that Re Y will only affect a handful of cases, I refer you to Lady Justice Black.


Lady Justice Black peers over the top of her glasses and says [and I quote] ... 'I would not expect to find cases bogged down with arguments as to whether the time spent with each of the parents or other aspects of the care arrangements are such as to make the case "a Payne case" or "a Re Y case"'

(Is that clear Matthew)

So you've all been dreaming... you're in a better place... I'm going to count back now, 3.... 2..... 1.....
"

[Editor – ‘Does anyone remember that moment when Bobby Ewing stepped out of the shower and he hadn’t been murdered at all, 18 months before?']

A dream?
Peut-etre c'etait un cauchemar pour les enfants’.

If you have a Kindle Reader, or have Kindle software on your IPAD, IPhone Android or Tablet, you can download this article, especially formatted for Kindle.

Click the article title below:

Payne Reviewed? A Very British Coup

More Kindle content will be coming soon from The Custody Minefield. Follow the blog, to find out when this content is being released.

To download Kindle software for your phone, PC or tablet, visit the following:

Kindle Software Applications

Wednesday, 29 June 2011

Relocation: FNF Press Release

PRESS RELEASE

Families Need Fathers

Rise in Child Abductions to Non-Hague Convention Countries Indicative of Wider Failures of the Family Justice System Concerning Relocation

HAGUE CONVENTION DOES NOT GUARANTEE RETURN: REFORM REQUIRED TO PREVENT MORE CHILDREN LOSING CONTACT WITH THEIR PARENTS

Families Need Fathers was saddened to see that the number of abductions to countries who have not ratified the 1980 Hague Convention on International Child Abduction has risen from 146 to 161 between 2009/10 and 2010/11. However, it would be wrong to think that the Hague Convention ensures that children can be returned quickly to their home country.

The approach of the family justice system to abduction and relocation cases is in need of an urgent overhaul if it is to protect the rights of children to maintain meaningful relationships with both parents. Ken Sanderson, CEO of Families Need Fathers, commented, “Child abduction destroys lives. Children are denied the love and support of a parent, and the parent left behind is placed in the intolerable position of not knowing where their children are, whether they are safe or when, if ever, they will see them again. Such abductions cause irreparable harm to individuals, families and their communities.

Of course, the international community needs to work hard to encourage more countries to sign the Hague Convention and address international child abduction with the urgency it deserves. We would be doing these families a disservice though if we were to consider the current implementation of the Convention amongst states that have ratified the treaty as a panacea to these problems. Relocation cases currently take far too long to be processed, during which time irreparable damage can be done to the parent-child relationship. Additionally, the costs of recovering abducted children are prohibitively expensive for most ordinary people to pursue, particularly where cases are dragged out over months, or even years. Access to justice must be open to all, and not simply those who can afford it.”

Ken Sanderson continued, “Our own legal system’s approach is in drastic need of an overhaul to prevent the continuing damage of child relocation. This issue goes beyond the Hague Convention. Payne V Payne, the case law which determines the courts’ decisions on relocation cases, gives undue weight to the desire of the parent wishing to move over that of the right of the child to maintain a meaningful relationship with both parents, in breach of the United Nations Convention on the Right of the Child. Indeed, even Lord Justice Wall has stated there is a “perfectly respectable argument” for this proposition. Our approach to relocation is outdated, ill-conceived, and will continue to do significant harm to family life until it is reformed.”

Michael Robinson of The Custody Minefield said “International parental child abduction is a growing problem. Our experience is that international treaties meant to ensure a child’s return are fine in theory, but in practice, often fail to see a child returned.

The government is well aware of the harmful impact on children of forced removal abroad, yet fails to address this in the current Family Justice Review. Despite assurances to me from Sir Tom McNally, Minister of State for Justice, that the review would look at this area of law, David Norgrove, the panel’s chair has affirmed in writing that this is not within their remit. The government must stop ignoring significant and identified risks to child welfare from international relocation.

Whether unlawful child abduction or court approved relocation, the effects on the child are the same. A dramatic change in living arrangements, the loss of contact with one parent and their wider family, change in school and loss of friends are likely to impact on a child’s psychological, emotional and educational development. We presented scientific evidence for this at Westminster last November. The government still does nothing but prevaricate.”

Saturday, 25 June 2011

Leave to Remove News

The father in the case Re D responds to Sir Nicholas Wall's recent u-turn.

19 June 2011

Continued psychological, developmental and educational harm and disadvantage to hundreds of British children in ‘Leave to Remove’ Relocation cases, as a direct consequence of the continued application of and reliance upon the outdated and discredited principles, suppositions and ideology of Payne v Payne (2001)

Dear Lords, Ladies and Gentlemen

I address this letter to all of the following recipients. For the benefit of new recipients, I have attached my open letters dated 20 December 2009, 14 February 2010, 14 March 2010, 18 November 2010 and 5 April 2011.

After reserving judgment in Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50 and giving himself three weeks in which to “reflect carefully” on the arguments presented by the litigant-in-person father, and to read the fifteen contemporary scientific papers exhibited - giving detailed evidence of the psychological, developmental and educational harm and disadvantage children are likely to experience in the absence of a close, frequent and meaningful relationship with both parents - Sir Nicholas Wall wrote in his publicised judgment that…

“…there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that [Payne v Payne] places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and… relegates the harm done of children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left behind parent… As I say, this is a perfectly respectable argument, and would, I have no doubt, in the right case constitute a ‘compelling reason’ for an appeal to be heard.”

However, one year later, in Re W (Children) [2011] EWCA Civ 345, Sir Nicholas Wall performed an inexplicable U-Turn on the issue of Payne v Payne, declaring:

“I fear that too much weight may have been given to some words of mine spoken in a judgment which I gave in an application to this court for permission to appeal in a relocation case. Whilst I do not resile from most of what I have said, I am of the clear view that undue prominence has been accorded to Re D…”

WHO, though, had been guilty of according “too much weight” and “undue prominence” to Re D????? Let’s find out…

a) SIR NICHOLAS WALL himself on at least 2 occasions!

Firstly, in an interview Sir Nicholas gave to ‘Family Affairs’ on 12 August 2010:

“In light of a) your comments in Re D, b) the Washington Declaration c) the new research from Dr Marilyn Freeman and Professor Parkinson and now d) the comments of Mostyn J in Re AR, where are we now on international child relocation? Is it still a question of finding a rich or tenacious (or both) litigant to push the right case to the Supreme Court before any effective review of Payne v Payne can take place?

"As I said recently in Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50, (which I am delighted to see that you have all read) there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that Payne v Payne places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and ignores or relegates the harm done to children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left behind parent. However, all relocation cases are (1) very difficult; and (2) highly fact specific. Re D was plainly not the case upon which to base a re-appraisal of Payne. Furthermore, as I also made clear in Re D, we operate a doctrine of precedent and it will be either for the government to change the law or for the Supreme Court to reconsider the issue in a suitable case. I do not think that a litigant would necessarily have to be either rich or tenacious to get to the Supreme Court, but a finely balanced case is likely to turn on the trial judge's exercise of discretion, with which it may be difficult to interfere."

http://www.familylaw.co.uk/articles/Sir-Nicholas-Interview-120810

Secondly, in a speech Sir Nicholas gave to the AGM of the ‘Families Need Fathers’ on 20 September 2010:

“I recently had to decide an application for permission to appeal in a “relocation” case [Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50]. The case did not involve Australia or New Zealand, but what used to be called Eastern Europe, and in my view the application had to be refused. The father who argued it, however, launched a “root and branch attack” on Payne v Payne, and I reserved judgment so that I could consider his arguments carefully.

“I went on to deal with whether or not there was a “compelling reason” for the Court of Appeal to hear the case. …There has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent and… relegates the harm done to children by a permanent breach of the relationship which the children have with the left-behind parent…as I say, this is a perfectly reasonable argument and would, I have no doubt, in the right case constitute a “compelling reason” for an appeal to be heard…”

http://www.familylaw.co.uk/articles/Wall200910

b) ANDREW SHAW of the Ministry of Justice.

Following an open letter I had sent to the Justice Minister and to the Prime Minister concerning the issue of Relocation, Mr Shaw replied on behalf of the Government on 8 March 2010 as follows:

“I confirm that the Ministry of Justice are carrying out a Review of the Family Justice System. The Review will aim to ensure that the Family Justice System supports good quality contact with both parents, as it is this which contributes to better outcomes.

Where precedent is cited, it is for the Courts to decide whether that is relevant. In your letter you mentioned Payne v Payne which is the leading judgment in Relocation cases. For Payne v Payne to be challenged and potentially overturned this would have to go to the Supreme Court in a case where there was genuine reason for an appeal to challenge the precedent set in Payne v Payne on the basis that the principles were mis-stated. With that in mind, you may be interested to learn that Nicholas Wall LJ in his judgment in Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50 on 9 February 2010 acknowledged that there is a respectable argument that the Court of Appeal judgment in Payne places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent (paragraph 33):

‘There has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters, and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and… relegates the harm done to children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left-behind parent.’

LJ Wall went on to say (paragraph 34):

‘This is a perfectly respectable argument, and would, I have no doubt, in the right case constitute a “compelling reason” for an appeal to be heard.’

Lastly, you mention in your letter about various scientific research papers… Whether any research influences future court decisions is a matter for the judiciary. The Lord Chief Justice has responsibility for judicial training. His responsibility is exercised through the Judicial Studies Board, which is an independent body chaired by Lord Justice Maurice Kay.

c) SIR NICHOLAS MOSTYN / High Court Judge of the Family Division.

“Mostyn J considered the authorities including Poel v Poel [1970] 1 WLR 1469, Payne v Payne [2001] 1 FLR 1052… and Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50”.

Paragraph 9 from Mostyn’s judgment in Re AR (A Child: Relocation) [2010] EWHC 1346 reads as follows: “More recently, in Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50 Wall LJ (as he then was) acknowledged the strength of the criticisms mentioned above. He stated at paragraph 33 that: There has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters, and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and ignores or relegates the harm done of children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left behind parent.”

http://www.familylawweek.co.uk/site.aspx?i=ed60336

d) PROFESSOR MARILYN FREEMAN / Professor of Family Law at London Metropolitan University, co-director of ‘The Centre of Family Law and Practice’ and Head of the Reunite Research Unit. In a speech to the University of Western Cape Conference on 18 March 2010, the learned Professor stated:

“Lord Justice Wall, in a hearing for permission to appeal a leave to remove (relocation) order, added his qualified support for a review of Payne v Payne on 9th February 2010 when, although deciding that the case he was hearing was not the right case for a challenge to Payne before the Supreme Court and thus refused the father’s permission to appeal, he stated:

"There has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters, and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and ignores or relegates the harm done of children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left behind parent”. He went on to say: "This is a perfectly respectable argument, and would, I have no doubt, in the right case constitute a 'compelling reason' for an appeal to be heard” (Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50). There are therefore signs that the Court of Appeal may be willing to revisit this position.”

http://www.millerdutoitcloeteinc.co.za/Paper%20-%20Freeman%20Marilyn.doc

e) HENRY SETRIGHT QC / Recorder and Deputy High Court Judge (Family Division)

In a presentation at the London Metropolitan University the eminent QC reiterated Wall’s critique of Payne v Payne in Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50

(see slide 19 of 26)

http://www.londonmet.ac.uk/fms/MRSite/acad/lgri/CFLP/Relocation/Relocation%2023%20Powerpoint%20May%202011.ppt#272,13,Share

f) ANNE THOMAS / Senior Partner at International Family Law Group, member of Reunite, past Chair of the Family Law Steering Group and member of the International Bar Association.

“In early 2010, in Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50, Wall LJ, now President of the Family Division, stated that “there has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters, and there is a perfectly reasonable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent and… relegates the harm done to children by a permanent breach of the relationship which the children have with the left-behind parent.” He went on: “this would, I have no doubt, in the right case constitute a compelling reason for an appeal to be heard.”’

http://www.iflg.uk.com/en/news/parliament-considers-reform-of-child-relocation-law

g) SANDRA DAVIS / Partner and Head of Family Law at Mishcon de Reya LLP, a Fellow of the International Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers, the author of International Child Abduction (Sweet & Maxwell, 1993) and a member of the Lord Chancellor’s Child Abduction Panel.

“In Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50 Sir Nicholas Wall said there was a perfectly respectable argument that Payne places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent. "In doing so", he said "it ignores or relegates the harm done to children [by the dislocation of their relationship with the parent left behind]". This, according to Sir Nicholas, would, in the right case, constitute a compelling reason for the Supreme Court to review the law on relocation. A couple of weeks ago the President of the Family Division gave the lead judgment in another relocation case, Re W (Children) [2011] EWCA Civ 345, in which he appeared to row back from his earlier decision in Re D. In the postscript to his judgment, Sir Nicholas retracted his use of the word "ignores" in Re D, adding "unless and until Parliament imposes a different test to that set out in section 1(1) of the Children Act 1989 relocation cases will remain... governed by Payne v Payne."

http://www.familylaw.co.uk/articles/SandraDavis14032011

h) DAVID HODSON / Deputy District Judge at the Principal Registry of the Family Division, High Court, London, a Fellow of the International Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers, author of A Practical Guide to International Family Law and chair of the Family Law Review Group of the Centre for Social Justice.

“England has probably the world's most liberal and generous relocation law and which has attracted much criticism from English lobbying groups, family lawyers and some judges. Lord Justice Thorpe writing in June Family Law (at p 565) about the conference says that if England were to subscribe to the [Washington] Declaration it would represent a significant departure from English relocation law principles. Yet he also accepts that it is not difficult to argue for a change in the law given the changes in parenting patterns over the past 40 years or so. Perhaps with a new President [Sir Nicholas Wall] who has been previously critical of English relocation law [Re D (Children)], we can have a new direction very soon, giving greater weight to continuity and ongoing relationship with the so-called "left behind parent". A change is very overdue.”

http://www.familylaw.co.uk/articles/david-hodson-on-international-family-law-0

i) HONG KONG FAMILY LAW ASSOCIATION

“Mr Justice Mostyn has said a review of Payne v Payne by the Supreme Court is urgently needed. It follows Lord Justice Wall, now President of the Family Division, adding his support last February in Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50 for a review of Payne.”

http://www.hkfla.org.hk/

j) JORDAN’S PUBLISHING

“In his judgment [Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50], Lord Justice Wall commented: "There has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters, and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and ignores or relegates the harm done of children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left behind parent."
He went on to say: "This is a perfectly respectable argument, and would, I have no doubt, in the right case constitute a 'compelling reason' for an appeal to be heard."

http://www.familylaw.co.uk/articles/perfectly-reasonable-argument-for-a-review-of-payne-says-lord-justice-wall

k) CATHERINE TAYLOR / Associate Solicitor / Healys LLP

“In February, Lord Justice Wall had called for a review of Payne v Payne [2001]. Lord Justice Wall had been hearing an application for permission to appeal a leave to remove order. He refused the father's permission to appeal, but said in his judgement, "There has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters, and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and ignores or relegates the harm done of children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left-behind parent [Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50)].”

http://www.healys.com/site/srvprivate/family_law_solicitors/family_law_further_information/family_law_review_of_payne_and_poel.html

l) JMW SOLICITORS LLP

“In the first six months of 2010, various high ranking family law judges made calls for a review of [Payne v Payne]. LJ Wall said, “There has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and… relegates the harm done of children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left-behind parent [Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50)].”

http://www.jmw.co.uk/services-for-you/family-law/articles/poel-and-payne/

m) WITHERS WORLDWIDE LLP

“…A recent Court of Appeal case Re D (2010) acknowledges that there has been considerable criticism of the leading case law which is widely seen as weighted in favour of relocating mothers. In his recent Judgment in Re D (Children), reported in February 2010, Wall LJ expressed his view that the Payne principles are ripe for review: "There has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters, and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and ignores or relegates the harm done to children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the ‘left behind' parent." However, Lord Justice Wall did not feel that this particular case was the ‘right one' to pursue this argument, and refused the father permission to appeal the decision that the mother be allowed to remove the children to Slovakia.

County Court and High Court Judges are duty bound to follow the Court of Appeal in Payne and as Lord Justice Wall acknowledged in Re D, the principles and guidelines laid down in that case can only be altered by legislation or overruled by a decision of the Supreme Court.”

http://www.withersworldwide.com/news-publications/729/moving-abroad-should-parents-be-on-an-equal-footing.aspx

n) KIM BEATSON / Partner & Head of Family Law at Anthony Gold LLP

“…there is now considerable momentum for a change of law in this area. In Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50 Wall LJ (as he was) acknowledged the criticisms of Payne and stated at para 33: “There has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters, and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and… relegates the harm done of children by permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left behind parent.”

http://www.anthonygold.co.uk/site/ang_articles/leave.html

o) AMANDEEP GILL / Jordan Publishing

“There has been considerable debate concerning leave to remove (LTR) cases following the comments made by Lord Justice Wall and Mr Justice Mostyn in Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50 and Re AR (A Child: Relocation) [2010] EWHC 1346 (Fam) respectively.

http://www.familylaw.co.uk/articles/amandeep-gill-s-analysis-0

p) VO LAW LLP

“Despite certain dissenting commentary amongst lower Court judges, these questions have remained largely untouched until very recently. In Re D [2010] EWCA Civ 50, Lord Justice Wall stated that there is a perfectly reasonable argument for the proposition that Payne places too much emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the parent seeking to remove the child. In his judgment, Wall LJ commented, “there has been considerable criticism of Payne -v- Payne in certain quarters, and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and… relegates the harm done of children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left behind parent ... there is a perfectly respectable argument, and would, I have no doubt, in the right case constitute a “compelling reason” for an appeal to be heard”

http://www.volaw.com/default.asp?contentID=1101

q) BRENDAN ROCHE / Barrister, 7 Bedford Row

“In February 2010, in the case of Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50, LJ Wall [noted] that there is a perfectly respectable argument that Payne v Payne “places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and… relegates the harm done to the children by a permanent breach of the relationship which the children have with the left-behind parent”. He had no doubt that, in the “right” case, this argument would constitute a compelling reason for an appeal to be heard.”

http://www.familylaw.co.uk/articles/flj0910BRENDANROCHE

r) DUNCAN LEWIS LLP

In Re D (Children) Lord Justice Wall has stated that there is a perfectly reasonable argument for the proposition that the Court of Appeal judgment in Payne v Payne places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent. In his judgment in Re D (Children), Lord Justice Wall commented: ‘There has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters, and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and ignores or relegates the harm done of children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left behind parent.’

Conclusion: The courts have engaged in a war between prioritisation between the Children Act 1989 and the Principles of Payne. The court has continuously observed the Childs welfare as paramount but there has been a vibrant and incoherent approach to these applications…”

http://www.duncanlewis.co.uk/childcare_news/Relocation_of_Children__(18_April_2011).html

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

In summary, those who Sir Nicholas Wall accuses of placing “too much weight” and “undue prominence” on his critique of Payne v Payne, as expressed in Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50 are:

a) Himself

b) The Ministry of Justice

c) A Professor of Family Law

d) The Judiciary of the High Court Family Division, and

e) Several eminently qualified and highly experienced Family Law practitioners

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

It surely behoves Sir Nicholas Wall to proffer a comprehensive explanation for his apparent U-turn on the issue of Payne v Payne.

For example, does Sir Nicholas now consider that the child-welfare arguments presented to him by the litigant-in-person father in Re D have lost their original potency?

The arguments against Payne, as presented in Re D, can be found at:

http://www.equalparentingalliance.org/2011/04/leave-to-remove-an-open-letter-from-father-of-re-d.html

Alternatively, does Sir Nicholas now no longer consider the scientific evidence, as presented to him in Re D, to be as powerful and persuasive as it was in 2010?

The scientific evidence, presented in Re D, can be found within the Custody Minefield Report, entitled ‘Family Law: Relocation: The Case for Reform’ at:

http://www.relocationcampaign.co.uk/index.html

Of course, Sir Nicholas has absolutely no obligation to provide comprehensive answers! He remains completely unaccountable for his actions and views, both to Parliament and to the General Public. He is untouchable.

Furthermore, Sir Nicholas expressed his critique of Payne v Payne in a second completely un-publicised judgment.

In April 2010, 2 months after Re D (Children) [2010] EWCA Civ 50, Sir Nicholas Wall gave judgment in Re D (A Child) [2010] EWCA Civ 593.

In this second judgment, Wall stated that:

“…there is a powerful body of opinion which takes the view that the traditional English way of dealing with [Relocation cases, as set out in Payne v Payne] pays too little attention to the damage caused to the child by the loss of the relationship which the child has with the left-behind parent and too much attention to the views of the departing parent, who invariably tells the court that she (and it is usually she) will be devastated if she is not allowed to go”.

Quite remarkably, Wall acknowledges the fact that, when acting for mothers wishing to remove their children overseas, their lawyers and barristers “invariably” seek to claim in court that their clients will be devastated if they are not allowed to go!

It is perhaps little wonder why Sir Nicholas decided NOT to make this second Relocation judgment public! Indeed, it was only brought to my personal attention by Lord McNally’s researchers.

Sir Nicholas Wall continues to decline to make any comment on this second judgment, and upon the implications it obviously has for his stance on Payne v Payne.

If the President of the British Medical Association had stated that there was a “perfectly reasonable”, “compelling” and “powerful” argument that Food Additive X relegated the harm done to children, but then proceeded to do absolutely nothing about it for nearly two years, I have no doubt that such a criminal dereliction of duty would have resulted in lengthy imprisonment!

The President of the Family Division stated that there was a “compelling” and “powerful” argument that Payne v Payne relegated the harm done to children, and yet has done absolutely nothing about it for nearly 2 years! Did Sir Nicholas have no professional or ethical duty to act without haste, and in accordance with the Precautionary Principle, particularly when the matter relates to the well-being of our children?

And how can it be that, after having been presented, last year, with all of the arguments and all of the powerful scientific evidence for the serious risk of child harm in Relocation cases, the Children’s Commissioner can still refuse to involve herself in this matter? Dr Atkinson has now even refused to deal with any further correspondence from me concerning Relocation cases!

In the recent case of Re W (Children) [2011] EWCA Civ 345, Sir Nicholas Wall abdicated responsibility for judge-made law and ‘passed the buck’ to Parliament. He distanced himself from his previous critique of Relocation law, attempted to suggest that people had mistakenly given his critique ‘undue prominence’, and reaffirmed Payne v Payne, stating that:

“…unless and until Parliament imposes a different test, relocation cases will remain… governed by Payne v Payne.”

…what is the position of Parliament???

A Summary of the Position of the Government:

Following my open letters, addressed to the Justice Minister, Mr Ken Clarke, and to the Prime Minister, Mr David Cameron, Lord McNally stepped forward to claim “ministerial responsibility” for Relocation law.

The position of the Government concerning Relocation law was clearly set out by Lord McNally in his letter to me (via my MP, Alistair Burt) dated 22 December 2010 (see attached):

“The Children Act 1989 already provides statutory protection to safeguard the welfare of children in cases of Relocation…the Act clearly requires the court to make the welfare of the child its paramount consideration…”

In other words, Lord McNally places responsibility for Relocation law firmly in the lap of the judiciary.

However, crucially, when assessing the ‘paramount’ welfare of the child, the judiciary is not in any way compelled by the Children Act to give full and proper weight to:

a) contemporary scientific research, and

b) the modern-day involvement of the so-called “non-primary carer” [the father] in the optimal development of the child.

The judiciary are thus at complete liberty to continue to assess the ‘paramount’ welfare of the child by adopting wholly un-scientific and plainly out-of-date suppositions and assumptions, originally pontificated upon by a judge in 1970.

In his letter, Lord McNally also affirmed that the Government is concerned and is interested in the issue of Relocation law, but that it wished to await recommendations for reform of Relocation law from the Family Justice Review before reaching any conclusions. To this end, Lord McNally confirmed that the FJR had been made aware of recent developments in Relocation law, and that it had been passed the latest Report from the Custody Minefield for its consideration. Lord McNally stated that it would be “premature” for the Government to reach any conclusions about legislative changes in Relocation law before it had seen the recommendations from the FJR. Quoting from his December letter:

“The Government has no current plans to change the substantive law on relocation. This is not due to any lack of concern or interest but because a Family Justice Review…has been launched… to make recommendations for reform.

The independent review panel has collected evidence from a wide range of sources and will have the opportunity to consider a wide range of issues, including Relocation cases. Policy officials working on the family justice review have been made aware of developments on Relocation including the latest Custody Minefield Report ‘Family Law: Relocation: The Case for Reform’. The review team is currently considering the evidence and will produce an interim report in Spring 2011, with a final report following in Autumn 2011.

I appreciate from his comments that Mr D’Itri is disappointed with this timetable. I hope, however, that you will agree that it would be premature for the Government to reach any conclusions about possible legislative measures before it has had the opportunity to consider the overall findings and recommendations from the review.”

Despite Lord McNally’s assurances, the FJR’s Interim Report, published at the end of March 2011, failed to address the issue of Relocation in any manner whatsoever.

In my open letter of 5 April 2011, I asked Lord McNally how the Government proposed to address the issue of Relocation law, in light of the disappointing Interim response from the FJR.

Lord McNally responded (again via my MP, Alistair Burt) by saying that Sir David Norgrove of the Family Justice Review – who had been copied in to my letter of 5 April 2011 – would be replying in detail to my concerns.

I received a reply from Sir David Norgrove on 1 June 2011 (see attached) as follows:

“With regards to the specifics of Relocation law, I am not able to comment in any depth on the issues you raise…

The specific issue of Relocation, and particularly the legislation surrounding the issue, was not within our remit and we did not take evidence on this question. I am grateful to you for passing on a copy of The Custody Minefield’s Report into the issue, but it would be remiss of me to make any judgments based on a limited understanding of the complexities involved.”

In short, Sir David has stated quite categorically that the FJR panel will NOT be addressing the issue of Relocation, and nor will it be making any recommendations. The ‘Relocation ball’ is now well and truly in the court of the Government!

On receipt of the letter from Sir David Norgrove, I immediately asked my MP, Alistair Burt, to request a full response from Lord McNally, as to the Government’s position on Relocation law. To date, no response has been received.

In the meantime, however, I was given a copy of a letter sent by Lord McNally to a concerned father, Mr K, on 23 May 2011 (see attached). In this letter, Lord McNally stated that:

“The Family Justice Review panel was not specifically asked to look at this issue [Relocation] in their terms of reference and therefore did not seek evidence on this”

I was naturally flabbergasted to read this new declaration by Lord McNally, because it flew in the face of his previous declaration, as detailed in his December letter to me.

How can Lord McNally have been so mistaken concerning the remit of the FJR? Surely he must have been in regular contact with Sir David Norgrove?

It is quite evident that the judiciary and the Government’s handling of the issue of Relocation is, at best, extremely shambolic, and, at worst, grossly negligent.

In either case, we must not accept it.

I therefore look forward to receiving an urgent and comprehensive response from Lord McNally to the issues raised in this letter, and full details of how the Government now proposes to address the issue of Relocation law, including a time-table for such action.

While we wait for the judiciary and the Government to act, hundreds of British children continue to be removed overseas each year, leaving behind their fathers, their extended families, their homes, their schools, their friends and their general way of life. These young and vulnerable children - who are already having to cope with the separation of their parents - are then expected to exhibit steely mental resilience in the face of the significant trauma of an overseas relocation.

Further unnecessary delay is completely unacceptable.

The Government has accepted the premise that children fare significantly better when they are permitted to remain in a meaningful relationship with BOTH of their parents. Yet it has consistently failed to address the most severe of all child/parent separations: that of overseas relocation.

While Mr Cameron sees fit to castigate ‘runaway fathers’ this Father’s Day - no doubt to the approval of the extremely powerful women’s lobby - his Government continues to ignore the issue of ‘runaway mothers’ in Relocation cases.

Cameron speaks of the vital influence played by his father in his own upbringing: lucky him! He would not have been so fortunate if his parents had separated when he was young and his mother had been given leave to emigrate!

Why does Mr Cameron stand idly by when hundreds of British children are routinely taken overseas, following the divorce of their parents, to be denied their Right to maintain a close, loving and meaningful relationship with their father?

What is good for children with married parents is surely also good for children with separated parents? I asked Mr Cameron this question a year ago. I still have not had an answer.

Yours most sincerely