Showing posts with label F v M. Show all posts
Showing posts with label F v M. Show all posts

Wednesday, 16 June 2010

Mr Justice Mostyn - A new judge in old shoes?

In an already noteworthy career and at only 50 years old, Mr Justice Mostyn QC had carved a reputation as the top divorce lawyer in the country, one half of the dream team who represented Paul McCartney; intelligent, widely respected, and a barrister who made his opponents tremble.

Only appointed to the High Court on 20th April, in less than 2 months, the Honourable Mr Justice Mostyn has given a landmark judgment which makes extraordinary reading.

On June 10th 2010, Mostyn gave his judgment in a leave to remove case. I have read many judgments, but none like this. This was remarkable.

Those who have followed my work will know I have been campaigning against the current application of legal precedent in leave to remove cases. The architect of that current 'binding' precedent is Lord Justice Thorpe. I believe Thorpe's reasoning in Payne to be ill-considered, unscientific, lacking in substance, and counter to the principles of the Children Act. I believe it has caused harm to thousands of British children. Sir Bob Geldof, who wrote the foreword in my Parliamentary Briefing Report on Relocation had the same opinion, and went further:

“The court is entirely informed by outdated social engineering models and contemporary attitudes rather than fact, precedent rather than common sense and modish unproven nostrums rather than present day realities. It is a disgraceful mess. A farrago of cod professionalism and faux concern largely predicated on nonsensical social guff, mumbo-jumbo and psycho-babble. Dangling at the other end of this are the lives of thousands of British children.”

You might expect the newly appointed Mr Justice Mostyn to be conservative in his opinions. You might expect him to be a traditionalist, reserved, not wishing to rock the boat. You would be wrong. His judgment, his opinion on Thorpe's guiding precedent in relocation cases was nothing short of ruthless. His reasoning cuts through the social guff and mumbo-jumbo that has beset leave to remove judgments under Thorpe’s guidance.

In 2008 as a QC, Mostyn came before Lord Justice Thorpe in a relocation case arguing against Thorpe’s own precedent with, in his own words ‘no little personal conviction’. The arguments were firmly repelled by Thorpe, and the orthodoxy of Payne v Payne reaffirmed. As any who have come up against Thorpe in a leave to remove case will know, Thatcher-like, the man ‘is not for turning’.

Two years on, with an international convention of judges having met in Washington in March and confirmed a child centred approach to deciding relocation cases, Mr Justice Mostyn went for the jugular. He clearly reasons out why the ideology in Payne v Payne is wrong. He cites the urgent need for the ideology in Payne v Payne to be reviewed in the Supreme Court. He turns the tables on 40 years of precedent, bringing child welfare back to the fore. In a single judgment, a herd of misguided sacred cows are slain. He reaffirms the desirability of shared parenting, questions the need for supervised contact where there is no evidence of risk, he reminds us of the child's Convention Right to Family Life, he reaffirms the paramountcy principle.

With such public criticism by the High Court of the Court of Appeal’s guidance, and that criticism having been so intelligently reasoned through, an urgent review by the Supreme Court has become a necessity.

Popular and controversial, Lord Denning was perhaps the last great judge, prepared to overturn what he considered to be ‘bad law’ in the pursuit of justice. It may be that Denning’s long vacant shoes have a new owner.

Download the full judgment here


Tuesday, 15 June 2010

Landmark Judgment in Leave to Remove Case

High Court Judgment calls for an urgent review of precedent in international family law by the Supreme Court

In December 2009, The Custody Minefield launched a campaign challenging legal precedent in relocation related family law which had existed for 40 years. Sir Bob Geldof wrote the foreword to our report backing our arguments. He condemned outcomes in the family courts as being barbaric and damaging to children. 58 Members of Parliament signed Early Day Motion 373 calling for better protection of child welfare in relocation cases (where one parent seeks to emigrate with the children following separation).

In January 2010, The Custody Minefield assisted the father in writing his submission which went before Lord Justice Wall in the Royal Courts of Justice. LJ Wall accepted the arguments put forward as compelling but that a delay caused by a retrial would not be in that family’s best interests. Lord Justice Wall, now President of the Family Courts, said:

There has been considerable criticism of Payne v Payne in certain quarters, and there is a perfectly respectable argument for the proposition that it places too great an emphasis on the wishes and feelings of the relocating parent, and ignores or relegates the harm done of children by a permanent breach of the relationship which children have with the left behind parent.

On June 10th 2010 in a landmark case in the Royal Courts of Justice:

The Honourable Mr Justice Mostyn accepted that the weighing of evidence in relocation cases is questionable, leads to too great an emphasis being placed on the disappointment of the relocating parent should their application for the children to emigrate be refused, and affords insufficient weight to the comparative importance of a child’s Convention Right to Family Life.

He further stated that it was his opinion that the that there was an urgent need for a review in the Supreme Court of the ideology set out in the existing legal precedent.

That the current ideology of the courts in international family law leads to selfless and virtuous parents being punished, and the selfish being rewarded.

Michael Robinson, who heads the relocation campaign said ‘I welcome this progressive judgment which recognises the importance of shared parenting and the current flaws in common law. Judicial decisions must be supported by contemporary child welfare related research rather than being based on out-dated precedent and unsubstantiated ideology. Research confirms that children face emotional, psychological and developmental harm when separated from a parent’s loving care.”

In Sir Bob Geldof’s words, in his foreword to our report last year “The court is entirely informed by outdated social engineering models and contemporary attitudes rather than fact, precedent rather than common sense and modish unproven nostrums rather than present day realities. It is a disgraceful mess. A farrago of cod professionalism and faux concern largely predicated on nonsensical social guff, mumbo-jumbo and psycho-babble. Dangling at the other end of this are the lives of thousands of British children and their families.”

The January and June 2010 case law and our briefing report can be downloaded by selecting the following links:

http://www.thecustodyminefield.com/Factsheets/AR_(A_Child_Relocation).pdf

Judgment given by Mr Justice Mostyn on 10th June 2010

http://www.thecustodyminefield.com/Factsheets/D_Children_2010_EWCA_Civ_50.pdf

Judgment given by Lord Justice Wall in January 2010

http://www.thecustodyminefield.com/Factsheets/TCM-LTR-ParliamentaryBriefingReport.pdf

The Custody Minefield Parliamentary Briefing Report on Relocation, Foreword by Sir Bob Geldof

michael.robinson@thecustodyminefield.com www.thecustodyminefield.com

The Custody Minefield is the most visited site on the internet on matters related to international family law and has led the campaign in recent years to reform the law in this area. This month, we received our 100,000th unique visit to our website.

- ENDS -